Dear TJPTSA members and TJ community at large:

I hope you and your families are enjoying time together this 4^th of July weekend. I wish I had good news regarding the state of the TJPTSA to share with you, but sadly I don’t.

First of all, I regret to inform you that two Executive Board Officers have resigned since Friday evening. As many of you are aware, President Elect Harry Jackson signed and mailed his version of the written response to the VA PTA on July 3, after a 4:3 vote during Friday’s Executive Board meeting to have his version serve as the “official response” from the TJPTSA Executive Board. First Vice President, Li Yang, who voted against sending the response prepared by Harry Jackson, gave me her resignation letter right after Friday’s meeting and also submitted it to the Board on Saturday morning. Second Vice President, Jun Wang, who actually voted for sending Harry Jackson’s response, submitted his resignation letter right after the response was mailed to the VA PTA on July 3. Their resignations have been accepted.

Furthermore, I regret to inform you that I have to call off the special membership meeting previously scheduled for Monday, July 5, at 6:30 PM due to the multiple threats of legal actions against me personally that were received in the past 36 hours from a certain group of people, who have apparently been working hard to prevent the removal of the non-compliant Officers (those called out in VA PTA’s June 23^rd Intent Letter) by the membership.

The special membership meeting was called in good faith and met the 7-day advance notice requirement according to our bylaws. The Board has received numerous messages from the community, including a Petition signed by more than 300 members, calling for the removal of non-compliant Officers. Nonetheless, a group of people is determined to challenge the sufficiency of the meeting notice in order to prevent the membership from exercising their rights. They are right that my family and I do not have any additional time or energy to deal with frivolous lawsuits after having spent the past six months enduring relentless personal attacks and false accusations against me on social media platforms and in the press, which have greatly harmed my health and taken my time away from my loved ones.

I am just a volunteer who has been trying to do what is the best for our students and our community. I believe the TJPTSA should not have to suffer from the grim consequences of the continued non-compliance of Board Officers (e.g., President Elect Harry Jackson’s continued media appearances to spread the misrepresentation of facts about the VA PTA after receiving the June 23 Intent Letter: July 1 Washington Times article, and June 25 Free Beacon Article).

Given the continued dysfunction, politicization, and combativeness of the Executive Board, Secretary Laura Marschoun and I believe that the best path forward for the sake of saving the TJPTSA would be to urge the resignation of the entire remaining Executive Board. I, as the President, and Laura Marschoun will resign immediately after receiving the resignation letters from President Elect Harry Jackson, Corresponding Secretary Hanning Chen, and Treasurer Himanshu Verma. Now is the time for all the Board Officers to put their personal interests aside for the benefit and greater good of the TJPTSA and the community.

Once the entire Executive Board resigns, all non-compliance cases of current TJPTSA Executive Board members as raised in the VA PTA Intent Letter should have been addressed. The membership can write to the VA PTA by July 7th requesting an extension of time for the election of a completely new Executive Board and for guidance on how this new election should be conducted. The TJPTSA will hopefully be able to carry on and continue to serve our community when it’s time to welcome the new Class of 2025 and when all the students will finally be back on campus in late August.

Sincerely,

Bonnie Qin

TJPTSA President

Dear TJPTSA members and the TJ community at large:

As many of you are aware, the Virginia PTA President, Ms. Pamela Croom, emailed an Intent Letter to the TJHSST PTSA Executive Board Members and a separate letter (with a link to the aforementioned Intent Letter at the end) to the TJPTSA general membership on the afternoon of June 23, 2021. The full Intent Letter and the letter to the general membership can be found on our website (https://tjptsa.com/2021-06-23-intent-letter-from-the-president-of-the-virginia-pta/). 

We would like to clarify that the VA PTA has NOT yet revoked our Charter. As indicated in the Intent Letter, “a recommendation has been made” to revoke our Charter in view of the reasons enumerated in the letter. The TJPTSA Executive Board has been provided an opportunity to submit a written response by July 7, 2021. Our elected officers will work on the written response. 

Thank you very much for your patience and understanding when we try to work out a solution to this grim situation. 

Sincerely yours, 

TJPTSA Elected Officers

Ms. Pamela Croom, the President of the Virginia PTA, emailed the following message to the general membership of TJHSST PTSA at around 4 PM on June 23, 2021.

At the end of this message, Ms. Croom included a link to a detailed Intent Letter that she emailed to the TJHSST PTSA Executive Board Members earlier that afternoon.

The text from both letters are attached below.

I. Ms. Croom’s message to the general membership of TJHSST PTSA

Dear TJ High School PTSA Members,

It is with a heavy heart and mind that the first communication I provide to you as valued members of Virginia PTA is one of the intent of revocation of the Charter for Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology PTSA (TJHSST PTSA).

TJHSST PTSA is organized and operates as a 501(c)3 subsidiary under the tax-exempt group umbrella of the parent organization Virginia Congress of Parents and Teachers, commonly known as Virginia PTA, and registered as the parent organization with the Virginia State Corporation Commission, Entity ID 00266536.

Throughout the past nine months, various members of Virginia PTA have attempted to work with members of your Executive Board, past and newly elected, to resolve various conflicts surrounding duties of officers and as board members of PTA. Any acting board member has an obligation to act ethically and avoid all conflicts of interest when making decisions for the PTA. Board members have the responsibility to recuse themselves from their responsibilities any time they have a problem keeping their fiduciary duty to the PTA, or, in other words, representing the PTA’s best interest.

While we have been successful in coming to an understanding of some issues, we have not been successful with resolving the following critical areas of concern:

·     Failure to adhere to PTA values and principles

·     Creation of a climate that discourages parent engagement

·     Failure to seek general membership approval for advocacy initiatives

·     Campaigning conflict of interest

·     Failure to follow Bylaws adopted by TJHSST PTSA membership

·     Conflict of interest and inappropriate representation of values and brand to the press

·     Bullying of elected officers and members who hold different views

The revocation of the charter has the following consequences, as outlined in the TJHSST PTSA Bylaws, Article 4: Relationship with National PTA, Virginia PTA and Constituent Associations, Section 16. Each local PTA/PTSA is obligated upon withdrawal of its charter by Virginia PTA to:

·     Yield and surrender all of its books and records and all of its assets and property to Virginia PTA or to such agency as may be designated by Virginia PTA or to another local PTA/PTSA organized under the authority of Virginia PTA.

·     Cease and desist from the further use of any name that implies or connotes association with Virginia PTA, National PTA or status as a constituent association of National PTA.

·     Carry out promptly, under the supervision and direction of Virginia PTA, all proceedings necessary for the purpose of dissolving such local PTA/PTSA.

We understand that you will have a lot of questions about how Virginia PTA will move forward. We will not have all the answers immediately as we are in the beginning stage of the process. TJHSST PTSA executive board is afforded the opportunity to respond to the notice of intent to revoke the unit’s charter no later than Wednesday, July 7, 2021. As TJHSST PTSA members, you can communicate with your executive board at executive@tjptsa.org.

It is unfortunate to have to provide this news but as a PTA, our values will remain what they have always been:

·     Collaboration: We will work in partnership with a wide array of individuals and organizations to broaden and enhance our ability to serve and advocate for all children and families.

·     Commitment: We are dedicated to children’s educational success, health, and well-being through strong family and community engagement, while remaining accountable to the principles upon which our association was founded.

·     Diversity: We acknowledge the potential of everyone without regard, including but not limited to: age, culture, economic status, educational background, ethnicity, gender, geographic location, legal status, marital status, mental ability, national origin, organizational position, parental status, physical ability, political philosophy, race, religion, sexual orientation, and work experience.

·     Respect: We value the individual contributions of members, employees, volunteers, and partners as we work collaboratively to achieve our association’s goals.

·     Accountability: All members, employees, volunteers, and partners have a shared responsibility to align their efforts toward the achievement of our association’s strategic initiatives.

For your reference, the letter provided to your executive board is included in this email.

Sincerely,

Pamela Croom

State President, Virginia PTA

II. The Intent Letter sent to the TJPTSA Executive Board (please click here for the PDF version of the Intent Letter)

June 23, 2021

Ms. Bonnie Quin, President and Executive Board Members
Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology PTSA
6560 Braddock Road

Alexandria, Virginia 22312

Dear Executive Board Members:

This letter will serve to notify Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology PTSA (TJHSST PTSA) that Virginia PTA has received numerous communications from PTSA members, community members and leaders asking for Virginia PTA to intercede on their behalf in regard to the operations of both the current and previous Executive Committee and Board.

TJHSST PTSA is organized and operates as a 501(c)3 subsidiary under the tax-exempt group umbrella of the parent organization Virginia Congress of Parents and Teachers, commonly known as Virginia PTA, and registered as the parent organization with the Virginia State Corporation Commission and for definition reference, Code of Virginia § 57-48. Definitions. “Parent organization” means that part of a charitable organization that coordinates, supervises, or exercises control over policy, fund raising, and expenditures or assists or advises one or more chapters, branches, or affiliates.

The continuous lack of respect and disregard for the authority of Virginia PTA, its elected officers, our bylaws, founding principles and values is unacceptable. In a communication provided to the TJHSST PTSA on Friday, June 11, 2021, it was provided, in part:

…Please let me know how I can assist in either moving past the stalemate that appears to exist within your association or come to some other mutually agreed upon solution as this situation has to come to a resolve immediately for the well­being of all involved…

The call for immediate action of the executive board members is due to our ongoing concerns about the damage being done by TJHSST PTSA as previously noted. Virginia PTA continues to receive requests for state intervention from TJHSST PTSA members who do not feel TJHSST PTSA is conducting business transparently or in the spirit of member approved bylaws.

As of the writing of this letter, it remains to be continual disregard and a series of violations of organizational standards. Additionally, the challenging and disrespect shown to the current President without adequate reason – other than having a majority vote – does not signify a board that respects the PTA Mission, Values, Purposes and Principles as provided in subsidiary bylaws.

Virginia PTA is extremely concerned about how the current TJHSST PTSA leadership continues to imperil the reputation and viability of the association. As an association we are committed to building a collaborative partnership among families, the school staff, and the community at large for the purpose of engaging families in their child’s education and creating a climate that supports the academic and social-emotional health of students. A guiding principle of our work is a commitment to inclusiveness and equity, knowledge of PTA and professional expertise. Throughout our work we respect and value the individual contributions of members, employees, volunteers, school staff and partners. As elected officers of PTA we have a shared responsibility to remain a guardian of the Mission, Brand and Association.

Failure to comply with good faith efforts, and an ongoing lack of adherence and challenge to the approved TJHSST PTSA bylaws dated June 7, 2019, and remedies extended by numerous Virginia PTA board members has brought us to the decision to move forward with the recommendation of revocation of the Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology PTSA Charter by the Virginia PTA Board of Directors. Our reasons are as follows but not limited to:

•      Failure to adhere to PTA values and principles

• Over the last several months the TJHSST PTSA’s commitment to creating a collaborative relationship between the principal and the PTSA has been compromised by the following actions:
• A letter issued on April 21st by the TJHSST PTSA Diversity Committee calling for disciplinary action and resignation of the principal.
• During the week of June 14th, some members of the newly elected Executive Committee (EC) advanced a false narrative to the press claiming that the principal was trying to assert authority over the PTSA.
• The newly elected EC is actively discussing stripping the principal of the voting rights granted under the bylaws adopted by General Membership and seeking to remove the principal from the TJHSST PTSA Executive Committee. Historically, the TJHSST principal has participated in EC meetings by providing reports, collaborating on initiatives to support students and staff, and contributed to the development of general PTSA meeting agendas.
• Attacking the principal, calling for her resignation and then attempting to restrict her participation in the PTA is a direct violation of the values and principles cited in our bylaws and directly impedes the ability of this EC to build critical partnerships between school and home.
• Creation of a climate that discourages parent engagement
• Virginia PTA has received numerous parent complaints that the TJHSST PTSA is not actively seeking volunteers and is not fostering a healthy relationship with the school.
• Many parents are afraid to speak out for fear of retaliation against themselves or their children due to the regular FIOA requests for parent-principal communication issued by outside associations in relation to the changes to the TJHSST admissions process.
• Parents attacking other parents on social media and in closed class level parent run Facebook pages has been left unchecked.

• Failure to seek general membership approval for advocacy initiatives
• Advocacy by the PTSA on behalf of their school community should always be non­partisan, based on PTA approved Resolutions, Position Statements and Legislative Priorities and grounded in the PTA Values, Objectives and Principles described in our bylaws. As a membership organization, it is critical that local units seek membership approval for any position statement or public policy letter. On April 21st, without approval of the Executive Committee or the General Membership, the TJHSST PTSA Diversity Committee issued a complaint letter to FCPS Region 2 Assistant Superintendent Dr. Zuluaga and FCPS Chief Equity Officer Dr. Williams and other outside associations calling for curriculum changes and the resignation of the principal due to a student developed lesson on social emotional learning. The letter includes calls to action that have not been discussed or approved by the local unit membership, nor was the Diversity Committee granted authority to speak on behalf of the PTA.
• Campaigning Conflict of Interest
• Candidates for the TJHSST PTSA 2021-2022 school year took the endorsement of an outside association and directly campaigned on a promise to advance a specific advocacy position. PTA advocacy positions may only be adopted following a PTA general membership vote and should never be used as a qualifications of any individual for a PTA elected officer position or a standing committee member. PTA elections campaigns should be run based solely on the qualifications and dedication of the volunteer to the school community and should never seek endorsement from outside associations.
• Failure to follow the Bylaws adopted by TJHSST PTSA membership
• President Elect calling for electronic votes.
• President Elect convening own EC meeting after scheduled meeting was cancelled by the President.
• President Elect presiding over a meeting without an invitation from the President.
• Some members of the Executive Committee have said they will not follow the bylaws regarding inclusion of the principal.
• Exclusion of the Principal on the Executive Committee when calculating quorum.
• Some members of the Executive Committee have attempted to create a committee to oversee a different 501c3.
• Conflict of interest and inappropriate representation of values and brand to the press
• On June 11t^h, several elected officers of the TJHSST PTSA condoned a misrepresentation of facts and direct attacks on Virginia PTA to the press and additionally used a cancelled Executive Committee meeting for personal gain and grandstanding by inviting members of the press to a live streaming of an executive committee meeting.
• On June 12th without a membership vote or approval of the President to speak on behalf of the members, several TJ PTSA Executive Committee members appeared in a news article asserting that their personal views and the positions of an outside association which several EC members are affiliated with represented the views and opinions of the TJHSST PTSA membership.

• Bullying of elected officers and members who hold different views.

o  During the week of June 14, 2021, the President Elect attempted to censure the President for an accurate interpretation of the bylaws. Aggressive emails have been sent by members of the Executive Committee challenging basic PTA processes and bylaws and questioning any support or help offered by the Virginia PTA. This has created a hostile volunteer environment and detracted from accomplishing any PTA work normally undertaken to transition to a new Board and prepare for the new school year.

The net result of your actions has not been to work in partnership but cultivated a hostile volunteer environment that prevents members from performing their elected duties. Therefore, as outlined in TJHSST PTSA Bylaws Article 4: Relationship with National PTA, Virginia PTA, and Constituent Associations. Section 15., a recommendation has been made to revoke your Charter. Virginia PTA Board of Directors reserves the right to revoke a constituent association’s charter, with notice, if the constituent association violates the ethics, policies, or principles of PTA or in any way jeopardizes the tax-exempt status or endangers the good name/good will of Virginia PTA.

As provided in Virginia PTA Bylaws Article 4: Relationship with National PTA, Virginia PTA, and Constituent Associations. Section 4., you are afforded the opportunity to respond to this notice. Your response is required in writing, addressed to the Virginia PTA Board of Directors, and sent certified mail receipt to Virginia PTA, Attention: Pamela B. Croom, President, 1027 Wilmer Avenue, Richmond, VA 23227 no later than Wednesday, July 7, 2021.

Sincerely,

Pamela B. Croom

Virginia PTA State President

SENT VIA EMAIL and CERTIFIED MAIL

cc: Dr. Ann Bonitatibus, Principal

Dr. Fabio Zuluago, Assistant Superintendent, Region 2

Dr. Scott Brabrand, Superintendent